One of the problems in the Western world right now, in my estimation, is that we see “freedom” as an artificially good thing in an abstract & idealized sense. humans, whatever else we are, are animals, and we have developed biological and cultural systems to deal with the universe. and nothing is “free” in the universe. you must obey the laws of physics: when you get punched in the nose it hurts, and when you eat rocks, they taste bad and make you sick, and break your teeth. that they are painful helps you try to avoid getting punched in the nose, and discourages you from eating rocks instead of apples, both of which are helpful if you wish to survive in the world. that is what the universe is “like,” yet in the western world we have abstracted out “freedom” as some kind of thing which is good in itself. I too think freedom is good, but not “in itself.” i think it is good because increased freedom for a larger number of people results in a better ability to solve important problems (firstly, how do we feed and clothe ourselves, and protect our families, and then other more complex, but less important issues).so librivox is a kind of demonstration that says: here are the rules. everything *else* is free, but the rules are not negotiable. and they are not negotiabale BECAUSE librivox has an objective that defines everything we do: “to make all public domain books available in audio for free.” the rules have been/are set in order to help us achieve that objective. everything is weighed against the objective, not against some abastract “freedom.”that is very powerful. i believe one of the driving evolutionary forces that has made humans successful is our desire to build and pleasure at building things.but building things takes discipline and dedication. it is always easier to sit on your ass and do nothing. and you are - in our very rich, and very easy world, “free” to sit on your ass and do nothing, but I don’t believe you will ever be happy if you take that approach. In order to be a happy human, I believe, you must build things.and *that*, to me, is what freedom means: the freedom to build the things you want to build. not freedom to do whatever you want, wherever you want, because “freedom” per se is sacred, but the freedom to pursue objectives you believe in.we have lost our sense of discipline, and I think that makes people very unhappy. I don’t mean that in any draconican sense, I just mean that in western world, we are told (by psychologists, parents, media, etc) that we can do whatever we want, that we are the centre of the universe, that our freedom is the most important thing and we have a *right* to it, that just believing in ourselves is enough to succeed. all of which is, frankly, bullshit.and that kind of thinking makes, I think, for unhappy people, and a disfunctional society, because we are NOT the centre of the universe able to influence it with our belief in how important we are; we are just a little part of it, subject to its laws. among which is, not much ever gets done without work.A few people have gotten involved with LibriVox, been impressed by the anarchist underpinnings, and argued that we needed to allow full freedom (ie to rant, to be disruptive etc). but librivox as a system works in part because of the laws of our little universe, some of which we understand, some of which are mysterious. I’ve been careful to try to defend and protect those mysterious things - even if I do not totally understand them (hence my defense of the “disclaimer” - I don’t want to mess with something that’s worked unless it is very clear that messing will make LV work better). I read recently somewhere that real freedom only comes from the pleasure of succeeding within constraints. Which seems to me to be about right.Quick payday advance loan
Credit score calculator
Florida repay teacher student loans title i
American modern home insurance
Get free credit report
Types of home loans
Union credit reports
Experian credit report
Credit card processing services
Credit life and disability insurance
Disability insurance companies
Homeowner insurance quotes
Life insurance company
Business credit reporting
Income tax debt relief
Instant payday loans completely online
Stafford student loan
Auto home insurance
Auto warranty insurance
To credit reporting
Debt settlement message board
Application card credit online
Credit report .com
Eliminate credit card debt
Credit reports on line
Federal fair credit reporting
Applications credit card fraud
Reporting credit card
Business credit card offer
Consolidation loan debt reduction
Automobile title loans
Non profit debt consolidation programs
And credit reporting
Bank of america student loan
Debt free letter settlement
Cheapest homeowners insurance
Stop credit card offer
Credit repair debt consolidation
Renters insurance quote
Auto loans online
Health insurance quote online instant
Credit repair info
Cost of long term care insurance
Visa card bad credit
Aarp long term care insurance
Aarp life insurance
Credit card debt solutions
Renters insurance policy
Insurance swinger life style
Bad credit home loans mortgage refinance interest only
Texas home loans
Insurance life whole
Card credit debt it settlement yourself
Exclusive auto insurance leads
Credit card machine lease
Canadian credit report score
Credit repair lawyers
Is a credit score
Disadvantages of debt settlement
Credit card college student
Student credit card uk
Business credit card machine
Consolidation debt free nonprofit
Debt settlement arizona
Florida refinance mortgage loans
Experion credit report
Total credit card debt
Paydayloans
Mortgage loan home mortgage rates mortgage refinance rates
Credit card rates uk
Free credit report government
3 bureau credit reports
Instant payday loans
Wachovia student credit card
Auto insurance search
Debt settlement how to get out
New home loans
About
Musings on open collaborative projects, (mostly non-software) with a focus on idealism and not money-making. The starting point is the LibriVox.org project. Mostly written by Hugh McGuire, but guest writers may join in as well. [more ...]
Contact
hugh(AT)dosemagazine[D0T]com
Pages
1 comment
April 3rd, 2007 at 2:05 pm
Pingback from hughmcguire.net · Freedom and Constraints